top of page
Search

Cooke's Recipe for Police Reform

Writer: Danny Shaw
Danny Shaw
13 hours ago
5 min read

For the future of policing in England and Wales, it is fast approaching decision time.


Will government ministers finally embrace the fundamental organisational reform that policing needs, accepting that it will entail huge upheaval and up-front costs? Or will they back away in the teeth of opposition and lose the momentum for change that has been gathering for over two years? 


This week, we may learn more about the government’s intentions, when Shabana Mahmood addresses the annual summit of chief constables and police and crime commissioners (PCCs) in London.  The Home Secretary is a strong supporter of structural reform, having published a bold White Paper in January which set out plans to revamp the current set-up with a National Police Service, a small number of regional forces and multiple local policing areas, at neighbourhood level. But she is now facing fierce resistance. 


Leading the charge are 29 PCCs (whose roles are set to be abolished) and two deputy policing mayors. Ominously for Mahmood, eleven of the 31 represent Labour. Several senior officers have expressed concerns too, among them Amanda Blakeman, the North Wales chief, who has accused Gavin Stephens, the National Police Chiefs’ Council chairman, of trying to ram through the reforms via a cabal of chiefs.


Criticism of the reforms centres principally on the second strand of the proposals - to mandate the merger of some of the 43 constabularies into regional forces. Lord (Sir Bernard) Hogan-Howe, the former Metropolitan Police Commissioner, was asked by Mahmood to suggest how many and which ones should be amalgamated. His findings, which have been submitted to, but not yet published by, the Home Office are believed to contain the dynamite recommendation of whittling down 43 to fewer than a dozen forces.


If you were drawing up a police service on a blank sheet of paper that may well be the design you’d come up with: think of the economies of scale and efficiencies you’d achieve through less duplication, clearer tasking and the pooling of specialist services and back-office functions. But the policing boundaries that would be torn up under such a model have existed for over half-a-century. It is quite something to say to the residents of Swindon (currently the responsibility of Wiltshire Police) that in future they will be part of the same force as the good folk of Land’s End (Devon and Cornwall Police), 240 miles away.  Similar examples can be found right across the country if the number of forces were to be slashed by three-quarters.


The PCCs and deputy mayors, in a well argued letter, have pleaded with Andy Burnham to “urgently intervene” to stop the mergers. “There is no evidence, academic or otherwise, that shows that larger forces perform better,” they write.  “The often-repeated argument that policing is performing certain functions 43 times is incorrect. We have mature and established regional and national collaborations, which are delivering better investigations and outcomes for our neighbourhoods.”


The initial cost of mergers (“a couple of billion quid”, Sir Stephen Watson, the Greater Manchester Police chief reckons) allied with the difficulty of levelling funding discrepancies between merged forces are the other main sticking points. But the most immediate problem now facing Mahmood and other advocates of force mergers is that Burnham, even before the PCCs’ letter arrived on his desk, is believed to be lukewarm. 


People who know the Prime Minister say he has no great interest in police reform (unlike social care, for instance) and has already made clear his desire to see greater devolution under a system of up to 40 mayoral strategic authorities with enhanced powers. Scrapping directly accountable constabularies in favour of a dozen mega-forces would not appear to be the Burnham way. Indeed, his pal Steve Rotheram, Mayor of the Liverpool City Region, has said: “The idea that we'd somehow get better policing by swallowing local forces up into a handful of enormous regional super-forces runs counter to the devolution agenda. It would be a strange step backwards to strengthen local democratic accountability with one hand, only to undermine that principle with the other.”


If Mahmood is to win her case, she will have to convince Burnham that mergers do not run counter to his devolution mission and that the political headache they will cause (imagine Piddington-style protests across the country) will be worth it. The Treasury will also want hard evidence that stumping up cash now will reap financial benefits in the years to come. The Home Secretary doesn’t have much time. If the merger plans are to get off the ground, legislation will be required - and there’s no prospect of that yet. A general election called in 2028 (which is what most pundits anticipate) could stop mergers in their tracks with the Conservatives and Reform UK against them too.


What proponents of mergers have in their favour is the unequivocal backing of influential police figures - Sir Mark Rowley, the Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Sir Andy Marsh, the newly-appointed Chief Inspector of Constabulary, Graeme Biggar, head of the National Crime Agency, Stephens and Watson. (The chiefs of a handful of cash-strapped constabularies, such as Cleveland and Gloucestershire, that see mergers as a route to financial survival are also supportive).  For the self-styled ‘system leaders’ of law enforcement, it is a rare moment of unity that must be grasped.  Sir Andy Cooke, who was also among the group until he retired as head of the inspectorate in March, says it would be a “massive mistake” not to go ahead with the police reform programme, mergers included.


“I have no doubt that that will improve the way that policing is delivered in this country, and it will save a fortune,” said Cooke at the Commons Home Affairs Committee, a fortnight ago. “That money can be redirected into keeping our citizens even safer. The situation is crying out for that. Policing cannot carry on as it is at the moment, and any delay in decision making for this White Paper on reform is, I think, a massive missed opportunity.”


Cooke’s comments are worth reading. After 41 years in the police service, at Lancashire and Merseyside, where he became Chief Constable, he no longer has any skin in the game. A vastly experienced, politically impartial observer of what works in policing, the 62-year-old cautioned against what he described as “misplaced localism” getting in the way of police reform. PCCs take note.  


“By adopting that localist approach, you are not going to keep your local community safer; you are just going to waste more money, be less effective and be more inefficient, and you will not have the benefit of better IT systems, better procurement approaches, and a National Crime Agency and counter-terrorism approach that works hand in hand, dealing with some of the same sorts of issues at the same time,” he said.


Will Burnham follow Cooke’s recipe for reform? Or will the devolution devotees win the day? It’s decision time, Prime Minister.


 
 
 

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

©2020 by Danny Shaw. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page